How to Make Great Pizza at Home!

How to Make Great Pizza at Home!

Who doesn’t love pizza? Delicious crust, topped with savory sauce and your favorite toppings. Really, what could be better? I think we all wish we could make pizza at home whenever that craving strikes. Equally true, many of us are intimidated by making pizza dough and the complexity of getting the toppings right, having a hot enough oven to cook it right, etc. There are actually several tips to making pizza at home that make it entirely possible to make pizza whenever you fancy it.

Some folks have gone the extra mile to install a specialty pizza oven, whether wood-burning or gas powered. And there are many that will set you back a ton of money. But there are some less expensive, more expedient methods, too.

Kalamazoo-backyard-pizza-oven

But the simplest and most accessible is to use a pizza stone in your oven at home or, even better, on your gas or charcoal grill. Yep, you can use the pizza stone on the grill!

If you are using a pizza stone with your oven, set the oven on bake at the highest temperature your oven can go. Put the pizza stone in the oven on a middle rack and let pre-heat for 30-45 minutes. Turn the broiler on, and let the pizza stone heat under the broiler for about 10 minutes, then revert to the bake setting…this will help heat the stone better, and you’re then ready to make and cook your pizza. If using a pizza stone on the grill, you’ll want to have the center burner (over which you put the pizza stone) on medium-high, and the outer burners on high. Again, preheat the stone for about 30-45 minutes. Your grill kettle should be 450-500 degrees, and pizza cooks in a short 4-5 minutes.

One other interesting idea is this fascinating gadget. It’s essentially pizza stone, cut into pieces and formed into a box, surrounded by grill-safe materials, all adding up to an inexpensive ($120-150) pizza box that uses your grill to heat, then encapsulates the heat for a hotter cooking temperature (about 550 F). We have one and have just started experimenting with it…could turn out to be a great tool!

bakerstone grill box

 

Now that we’ve talked about the cooking methods and tools, let’s talk about the pizza itself!

The Dough
The best discovery I’ve ever made is to look to your local pizzeria (the one that makes your favorite pizza) for the dough. I don’t mean using them for inspiration to make the dough…see if they will sell you their dough! Surprisingly, many of them will. And they make it a heck of a lot more often than you will ever do. So leverage their talent and use their dough if you don’t want to make your own. We buy ours in San Francisco from Delfina Pizzeria, and it is fabulous! Naturally, there are also tons of great books and online resources if you want to try your hand at making your own.

The Sauce
Keep it simple. For a tomato based sauce, we use a simple blend of San Marzano tomatoes, olive oil and sea salt. That’s it. Very simple, very clean, and let’s you taste the tomatoes and toppings easily. For a while sauce, best to use simple panna (Italian cream) if you can find it. Or make a light béchamel sauce, by making a butter and flour roux, cook until the flour taste is gone (about 4 minutes), gradually stir in milk until thickened, smooth and bubbly, then grate in some fresh nutmeg. Or finally, you can be more inventive. Our fave right now is an onion sauce – made by tossing sliced onions with red wine vinegar and thyme, then caramelizing in a little olive oil, finally adding cream and reducing it heavily, then puréeing the whole thing for the base sauce. Yum!

Toppings
Be inventive! That onion sauce? We follow the recipe for the Onion Pie in Jim Lahey’s book, My Pizza. That great sauce is topped with some mozzarella, olive oil, parmesan and a ton of scallions. It’s delicious.

onion pie

The trick is to try flavor combinations that you like already, but in pizza form. Try figs, prosciutto, balsamic fried onions and goat cheese topped with fresh arugula. Or try your favorite sausage, fresh mushrooms, fontina cheese and red chili flakes.

One of our other recent faves is also from Jim Lahey, which is tomato sauce with mozzarella, sausage, red chili flakes and then topped with paper-thin slices of fresh fennel bulb. Wonderfully fragrant and delicious.

fennel and sausage

A couple of closing notes on pizza making at home. Try a few great books, like the one I recommended, My Pizza by Jim Lahey, or The Pizza Bible, by Tony Gemignani. Find a book that gives you inspiration. Secondly, invite friends over to try a bunch of different pizzas. And finally, remember to experiment and have fun!

Share your favorite pizza pics in a comment – I’d love to see what devices you’re using and what topping combos you discover!

Buon appetito!

Share This Post

4 Comments

  1. Lisa Crooke - August 28, 2015

    Thanks for sharing Whit!

    All awesome… and can’t wait to try your simple pizza sauce! We make pizza on a regular basis…

    My favorite crust recipe is from Jamie Oliver. http://www.foodnetwork.com/recipes/jamie-oliver/pizza-dough-recipe.html#lightbox-recipe-image

    I love this recipe because there is a 1 hour time frame to raise the dough so it can be made on a week night. It also freezes very well. I will make a full batch and then take the dough we do not use and break into single serving balls, wrap in wax paper and freeze — super easy to pull out for quick weeknight meal.

    Finally, to add to your point about having a low cost pizza oven, I agree. We used to make our pizzas on a pizza stone on our gas grill and then always had to put them under the broiler for a blast of heat to get the top properly cooked. Last year we purchased a propane gas powered pizza oven from sur la table and we LOVE it. The one we purchased is http://www.surlatable.com/product/PRO-1247444/Pizzeria+Pronto+Outdoor+Pizza+Oven

    We get perfect pizzas and calzones with this thing and we have made tons of pizzas….. highly recommend it!

    Thanks for your amazing food blog!! Keep it coming! 🙂

    Bon Apetit!!

    Lisa

  2. Patrali - February 20, 2016

    Yummy! Have you ever tried curried or tandoori chicken topping with a celantro/ paneer(Indian cheese) garnish?

    • Whitney - March 21, 2016

      No, but what a great idea! I also thought about modifying the onion pizza recipe, to put some Indian spices in the onions (garam masala, chile powder, mustard seed, cumin seed and coriander seed), then top with cilantro, curry leaves and sliced fresh chiles.

Leave a reply